Toilet Flange Repair Kit Reviews

Part 1:

**Introduction**

It’s always important to stay on top of our home repairs, and that includes the toilet flange. A faulty toilet flange can lead to unwanted problems such as water leakage and annoying rattling noises. Hence, today we will be highlighting the importance and delivering detailed reviews of 10 different Toilet Flange Repair Kits. Independent reviews of each model will include a detailed examination of features, pros, cons, and an in-depth breakdown.

**1. Product Title: Oatey 43538 ABS Cast Iron Flange Replacement Kit**

The Oatey 43538 ABS Cast Iron Flange Replacement is a highly durable, easy-to-install repair kit made to cater to those with leaking or broken toilet flange issues.

**Pros:**

– Easy installation process
– Durable construction
– Versatile, fits into a variety of cast-iron pipes

**Cons:**

– The plastic construction might not be as sturdy as metal
– Additional hardware might be necessary for installation

**Details:**

This Oatey model is built with ABS plastic and weighs about 8 ounces. It’s designed to fit into 4-inch diameter cast-iron pipes for a secure and tight fit. Despite its lightweight plastic construction, the repair kit is impressively durable and offers an easy installation process. Given its affordable price and quality, the Oatey 43538 Flange Replacement Kit is ideal for homeowners after a simple, quick, and effective toilet flange solution.

**2. Product Title: Danco 9D0010672X Toilet Flange Repair Kit**

Danco’s 9D0010672X Toilet Flange Repair Kit is known for its compatibility with various pipe sizes and types, making it an efficient and reliable choice for homeowners trying to mend their faulty toilet flanges.

**Pros:**

– Resilient stainless-steel components
– Works perfectly on different pipe sizes
– Easy to install

**Cons:**

– Installation instructions can be confusing
– The metal flange might corrode over time

**Details:**

This kit by Danco weighs about 8 ounces and is composed of strong stainless steel. It comfortably fits into both 3 and 4-inch pipes, and securely fastens into lead or cast iron pipes. Although some customers have found the installation instructions a tad confusing, once set-up, it does an excellent job. Given these attributes and the brand’s reputation, the Danco 9D0010672X is suitable for those after a resilient and dependable flange repair kit.

**3. Product Title: HydroSeat DABS Toilet Flange Repair**

HydroSeat offers a durable and robust Toilet Flange Repair Kit that ensures a tight seal between the toilet and the pipe, indemnifying against water leaks.

**Pros:**

– Extremely sturdy construction
– Easy to install
– Resistant to corrosion

**Cons:**

– Slower to install than others
– Might not fit some pipe types

**Details:**

This HydroSeat repair kit weighs 1.35 pounds with a highly robust steel and aluminum construction. It offers a rubber funnel that provides a tight seal to effectively combat water leaks. Despite it being a bit slower to install than other repair kits, it assures you a more secure and leak-proof fix. HydroSeat’s DABS Toilet Flange Repair kit is a perfect choice for the long-term designer solution.

**4. Product Title: SIOUX CHIEF MFG PBS44AZ 4″ Push-Tite Gasketed Closet Flange**

The SIOUX CHIEF MFG’s 4″ Push-Tite Gasketed Closet Flange is for the DIY enthusiast who is up for a quick and simple toilet flange repair.

**Pros:**

– Corrosion-proof
– Simplified installation process
– Fits multiple pipe types

**Cons:**

– Plastic construction might not be very durable
– Gasket may require replacement over time

**Details:**

Weighing about 4.8 ounces, this flange repair kit features a plastic design that prevents corrosion and suits a variety of pipe sizes. The primary feature of this tool is its push-in installation, allowing the user to set up without needing additional tools or expertise. Despite its plastic makeup, the SIOUX CHIEF MFG PBS44AZ 4″ Push-Tite Gasketed Closet Flange is perfect for those seeking an easy-to-install and cost-effective repair solution.

**5. Product Title: Fluidmaster 7530P8 Universal Better Than Wax Toilet Seal**

Fluidmaster’s 7530P8 Universal Better Than Wax Toilet Seal is an innovative toilet flange repair kit that does an excellent job of preventing leaks while ensuring a versatile fit for all toilet types.

**Pros:**

– Fits all toilet and flange types
– Zero mess: no wax involved
– Does a great job of sealing

**Cons:**

– Many parts to set up
– May not work on all pipe types

**Details:**

This Fluidmaster repair kit weighs just 4 ounces, including a wax-less toilet bowl gasket and a universal flange. The “Better Than Wax” assembly seals perfectly without causing a messy clean-up associated with traditional wax rings. Despite its small size and numerous components, Fluidmaster’s 7530P8 is recommended for the homeowner looking for a universal and mess-free solution.